Florida Criminal Defense Attorney - William W. Hanlon
Tampa Criminal Lawyer Prevents 5 Year License Suspension The defendant was arrested on another driving while license suspended charge qualifying him for habitualization and a five year suspension of his license.
911 Call Not "Testimonial" hearsay A 911 call that is admitted under the excited utterance or spontaneous statement exception under 90.803(1)and (2) is not "testimonial" hearsay and is admissable as evidence. Bartee v. State, 31 F.L.W. D815 (5th DCA 3/17/2006). The Fifth district relied on the analysis set out in Crawford v. Washington by the United States Supreme Court. By contrast the 5th DCA felt the statements made to law enforcement by the victim were testimonial in nature, and not admissable. The Court felt that the statements were made after the defendant had left the scene, and the statements were in direct response to police questioning. In addition, the victim had every reason to believe that her statements could be used to prosecute the defendant. Once the Court determined that the statements to police were testimonial in nature the court then addressed the second part of the analysis. Neither side was ever able to produce the victim as a witness, and she was never subject to cross examination. As a result, the statements made by the victim to law enforcement should not have been admitted. While Mr. Bartee's case was reversed on appeal, the reversal only pertained to the burglary charge and the convictions as to false imprisonment and battery were upheld.
Tampa Criminal Defendant Avoids Conviction of Refusal to Obey FACTS: The defendant was charged with Failure to Obey the Command of a Law Enforcement Officer. He was leaving the St. Pete Times Forum when he was stopped by a law enforcement officer in traffic. The law enforcement officer claimed he commanded him to stop his vehicle, and he refused to do so. |
Recent UpdatesSeptember 22, 2006 August 28, 2006 August 22, 2006 ArchivesWeb ResourcesFindLaw |
Recent Court Wins
The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for individual advice regarding your own situation.
Copyright © 2008 by The Criminal Defense Group. All rights reserved. You may reproduce materials available at this site for your own personal use and for non-commercial distribution. All copies must include this copyright statement.